Welcome to Axure Community Site Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Victor's Blog

Oh Visio!

A few months ago an article called Storyboarding Rich Internet Applications With Visio written by Bill Scott was published on Boxes and Arrows, a popular Information Architecture site.

In the article, Bill goes through an example of using Visio to design an inline editor for changing photo titles in a photo manager. The end result is that you can double-click on each step in a storyboard diagram to show layers of the diagram representing the various states of the inline editor. Cool stuff.

I thought it would be interesting to prototype the design in Axure RP 4. I created the inline editor using a dynamic panel and created the editor with an image as a master. I repeated the master on the Home page to better represent what the experience would be like in the actual application. After doing that, I noticed that editing a title caused the save and cancel buttons to overlap with the image to the right. Usability issue? Maybe, maybe not, but it made me think twice about the design.

You can download the file here or view the prototype here. The prototype was designed for changing the title to "Water lilies" as described in the annotation on the Save button.

Published Wednesday, February 22, 2006 11:10 PM by victor

Comments

 

kai said:

hi victor,

thanks for the example.
i like visio's ability to easily create wireframes, but miss the possibility to add interactive funcionality to it.
so i searched the web and stumbled over bill scott's article you mentioned. i thought that this is still not what i was looking for and now i discovered that you used just that example to show the abilities of axure, which seems to be a very promising tool.
but by playing with your example i realized that changes aren't made persistant, and that the 'click to edit' hint appears at severeal places at once, disturbing the user experience.
do you know if it's possible to eliminate that flaws, to have a real impression of an 'working prototype'?
and, additionally, do you know if there is a possibility to realize dialog boxes in axure?

thanks,

kai
April 2, 2006 1:41 PM
 

JackO said:

Visio, to my mind is a jack of all trades and a master of none - which is, I guess, exactly what Microsoft wants it to be.  Axure can't do a lot of things that Visio can, but what it does do, it does far better than Visio's designers dreamed of.
 
There comes a point where the easiest way to create what Kai call a 'working prototype' is to drag out Visual Studio and create the application using XML as your datastore.  Problem is, you can't turn out nearly the same number of HTML pages that way.


April 3, 2006 10:13 AM
 

victor said:

Kai, the ability to persist the data is a feature we are considering, but it is not currently available in Axure RP. I am not quite sure what you mean by 'click to edit' appears in several places. It should be hidden after mousing out of the respective label.

Axure RP allows you to open popup windows in an interaction which can be used to demonstrate dialog boxes. There is also the ability to close the popup window as well as redirect the opening window from an interaction in the popup window.
April 11, 2006 1:20 PM
Anonymous comments are disabled